Journal of Socio-Cultural Studies of Khorasan

Journal of Socio-Cultural Studies of Khorasan

Etymology and Transformation of the Name and Status of Qaen and Qohestan

Author
Assistant Professor of History and Civilization of Islamic Nations, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Mashhad
Abstract
Introduction
Qohestan, a province in southern Khorasan with Qaen as its center, boasts a history dating back to at least the Sassanid period. This rich historical background has prompted numerous studies on the region, particularly on the history of Qaen and Qohestan. Many of these works delve into the etymology of the province's name, offering various interpretations. Some suggest it stems from a transformation of the word Gavīn (meaning ‘cow’), others link it to Qabil (the son of Adam), and some attribute it to a Mongol origin. However, these interpretations appear inaccurate. Qaen predates the Arab and Semitic cultural influences in the region, rendering the Mongol origin hypothesis implausible. Similarly, the idea that Qohestan derives from the word Quh—attributed to the presence of qanats in the area—lacks merit. The water system in Qohestan was not significantly different from its neighboring regions, nor did it feature a greater number of qanats. The broader historical changes, such as the region’s rise and decline, its renaming, and the relocation of its capital, remain topics of scholarly debate. This study aims to explore the etymology of Qaen and Qohestan while shedding light on the primary factors behind the region's historical transformations.
 
Methodology
This study adopts a descriptive-analytical approach to critically evaluate previous research. It relies on library-based research to investigate the etymology of the names Qaen and Qohestan, as well as to explore the factors contributing to the region's prosperity, decline, and shifts in its administrative center.
Findings and Conclusion
The repeated invasions and occasional dominance of foreign powers in Iranian territory have led to significant cultural intermixing and the influence of foreign cultural elements. One prominent result of this cultural exchange is the variety of narratives surrounding the etymology and attribution of many Iranian cities to Greek, Semitic, or Mongol myths and figures. This article examines how these influences shaped the etymology of the city of Qaen. While the history of Qaen and the broader Qohestan region predates the Arab Muslim conquest (circa 30 AH), Islamic sources often attributed the etymology of Qaen to Semitic myths, with some even proposing a Mongol origin. However, historical evidence suggests that the name Qaen, referred to as ‘Kayen’ in Sassanid-era sources, originates from the term ‘Karen’. Karen was the name of a prominent family in pre-Islamic Iran, known for its influence across various regions, including Qohestan. This family likely played a key role in founding or developing the city of Qaen. Additionally, the term ‘Kohestan’ was historically used to describe several provinces or regions in pre-Islamic Iran, all characterized by their mountainous terrain. After the advent of Islam, this term evolved into ‘Quhestan’ or ‘Qohestan’, retaining its original meaning of a ‘mountainous region’.
An analysis of events during the early years of the Arab conquest reveals that the absence of references to the capital and other districts of Qohestan until the fourth century AH likely stemmed from the resistance of the Qohestani people to Arab control and the widespread devastation caused by the conquest. The hereditary rule of the Simjuri family over the province during the Samanid period (287–395 AH) marked a turning point in the region’s revival. This era saw the formation of Greater Qohestan through the annexation of provinces such as Tabas and Turshiz, as well as the emergence of its districts in historical sources from the fourth century. The Ismaili dominance over Qohestan in the latter half of the fifth century, characterized by repeated conflicts with the Seljuks and significant destruction—particularly in Qaen and Turshiz—further shaped the region’s trajectory. Despite these challenges, the Ismaili policy toward the Mongols shielded the area from Mongol invasions, transforming it into a refuge for those fleeing Mongol massacres. However, this protection ended with the establishment of the Ilkhanid dynasty. Under Hulagu Khan, Qohestan became a target for invasions, resulting in widespread massacres, particularly in the city of Tun. Following the fall of the Ismailis, Qohestan was freed from continuous conflicts with neighboring powers, and conditions for reconstruction began to improve. This resurgence was facilitated by the Ilkhans, who designated the region as a hereditary domain for a Mongol family. During the Timurid period, Qohestan experienced a second wave of prosperity. The prominence of the Qaeni family within the Timurid administration brought increased attention and investment to the region. Additionally, the transfer of the Timurid capital from Samarkand to Herat provided economic and social benefits to neighboring areas, including Qohestan. However, the decline of the Timurid dynasty, marked by the capital's relocation from Herat to western Iran and the constant incursions of the Uzbeks in eastern Iran, pushed Qohestan into a state of decline. The Safavid policy of granting independence to various cities within Qohestan further fragmented the region, ultimately leading to the collapse of its unity and the disappearance of the name "Qohestan" from common usage.
A major transformation in the region occurred during the early years of the hereditary rule of the Alam family, under the reign of Nader Shah Afshar (1148–1160 AH), when the provincial capital was relocated from Qaen to Birjand, and the province was renamed from Qaen to Qaenat. Several factors likely influenced this decision, the most prominent being the Alam family’s origins in Sarbisheh, near Birjand, and Birjand’s more central location within the province. This strategic positioning ensured a safer distance from neighboring provinces, such as the hereditary domains of Tabas, Torbat-e Heydariyeh, and Herat. The transfer of the capital to Birjand spurred the settlement’s growth into a relatively large city, while simultaneously reducing the prominence of Qaen, which became the province’s secondary city.
Keywords

Subjects


References
Allah-Yari, H. (2014). Robat-e Pariyan [Robat-e Pariyan]. In G.-A. Haddad-Adel (Ed.), Encyclopedia of the Islamic World (Vol. 19). Tehran: Foundation for the Islamic Encyclopedia.##Amoli, O. (1969). Tarikh-e Royan [History of Royan] (M. Sotoudeh, Ed.). Tehran: Bonyad Farhang-e Iran. [in Persian]##Aramjo, A. (2010). Barrasi-e tahavvolat-e siasi, eqtesadi va ejtemai-e velayat-e qaenat dar dowre-ye qajarieh [A study of the political, economic, and social changes of Qaenat county in the Qajar era] (Unpublished master’s thesis). University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran. [in Persian]##Asnad va Mokatabat-e Tarikhi az Teymur ta Shah Esmail [Historical Documents and Correspondences from Timur to Shah Ismail] (1977). Tehran: Bongah-e Tarjomeh va Nashr-e Ketab. [in Persian]##Ayati, M. H. (1992). Baharestan dar Tarikh va Tarajom-e Rijal-e Qaenat va Ghahestan [Baharestan: A History and Biographies of Qaenat and Ghahestan]. Mashhad: Chap-e Sheerkat-e Sahami. [in Persian]##Azami Sangsari, C. A. (1976). Qarenvand ya Sokhrayian [Qarenvand or Sokhrayian]. History Studies, 11(3), 201–244.##Bal’ami, A. A. (1999). Tarikhnameh-ye Tabari [The History of Tabari]. Tehran: Soroush. [in Persian]##Baladhuri, A. ibn Y. (1988). Futuh al-Buldan [Conquests of the Lands]. Beirut: Dar wa Maktabah al-Hilal. [in Arabic]##Bayhaqi, A. al-F. (1995). Tarikh-e Bayhaqi [The History of Bayhaqi]. Tehran: Mahtab. [in Persian]##Bayhaqi, A. al-H. A. ibn Z. (1938). Tarikh-e Beyhaq [History of Bayhaq] (A. Bahmanyar, Ed.). Tehran: Ketabforoushi Foroughi. [in Persian]##Bellew, H. W. (1874). From the Indus to the Tigris: A narrative of a journey through the countries of Balochistan, Afghanistan, Khorassan and Iran in 1872. London: Trübner & Co.##Daneshyar, M. (2015). Tahavvolat-e Siyasi va Eghtesadi - Ejtemai Khorasan dar Dore-ye Qajariyah (1266-1332 Q/1850-1914) [Political, economic, and social transformations of Khorasan during the Qajar era]. (Unpublished doctoral dissertation), University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran. [in Persian]##Daneshyar, M. (2018). Sistan. Encyclopedia of the Islamic World. Tehran: Foundation for the Islamic Encyclopedia. [in Persian]##Dehkhoda, A. A. (1998). Loghatnameh [A dictionary]. Tehran: University of Tehran. [in Persian]##Eskandar Beg Turkman Munshi (1971). Tarikh-e Alam-Ara-ye Abbasi [The world-conquering history of the Abbasids]. Tehran: Amir Kabir. [in Persian]##Estarabadi, M. M. (1998). Jahan-Gosha-ye Naderi [The world conqueror of Nader]. Tehran: Anjoman Asar va Mafakher-e Farhangi. [in Persian]##Etesam al-Molk, M. K. K. (1972). Safarnameh-ye Etesam al-Molk [The travelogue of Etesam al-Molk]. Tehran: Ferdowsi Printing House. [in Persian]##Fanoudi, S. A. (2004). Tarikh-e Qa'enat (Mirat al-Maknoonat fi Tarikh-e Qa'enat) [History of Qa’enat]. Tehran: Hirmand. [in Persian]##Forqani, M. F. (2002). Tarikh-e Esma'iliyoun-e Qohestan [The history of the Ismailis of Qohestan]. Tehran: Society for Cultural Heritage and Honors. [in Persian]##Fraser, J. B. (1825). Narrative of a journey into Khorasan in the years 1821-2. London: Longman.##Gardizi, A. S. A. al-H. ibn al-Z. ibn M. (1984). Zayn al-Akhbar [The adornment of histories]. Tehran: Donyaye Ketab. [in Persian]##Golestaneh, A. al-H. ibn M. A. (1977). Majmal al-Tawarikh [The concise histories] (M. T. Modarres Razavi, Ed.). Tehran: University of Tehran. [in Persian]##Hafez Abru, S. al-D. A. K. (1996). Joghrafiya-ye Hafez Abru [The geography of Hafez Abru]. Tehran: Miras-e Maktoub. [in Persian]##Hafez Abru, S. al-D. A. K. (2001). Zobdat al-Tavarikh [Essence of histories]. Tehran: Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance. [in Persian]##Hafez Abru, S. al-D. A. K. (2020). Joghrafiya-ye Hafez Abru, Bakhshe Khorasan [Geography of Hafez Abru: Khorasan section]. Tehran: Mahmoud Afshar Publications. [in Persian]##Haft Keshvar ya Sur al-Aqalim [Seven countries or the forms of the climes] (1974). Edited and Annotated by M. Sotoudeh. Tehran: Foundation of Iranian Culture. [in Persian]##Hamdallah Mustawfi (1983). Nozhat al-Qolub [The pleasure of the hearts]. Tehran: Donyaye Ketab. [in Persian]##Hatami, H. (2001). Joghrafiya-ye Shahrestan-e Qainat [Geography of Qainat county]. Mashhad: Astan Quds Razavi. [in Persian]##Hedayat, R. Q. K. (2001). Tarikh-e Rowzat al-Safa-ye Naseri [The history of the Rose Garden of purity, Naseri version] (J. Kianfar, Ed.). Tehran: Asatir. [in Persian]##Hodud al-'Alam min al-Mashriq ila al-Maghrib [The boundaries of the world from the East to the West] (1983). Tehran: Tahouri. [in Persian]##Hosseini Monshi, M. ibn I. (2007). Tarikh-e Ahmad Shahi [The history of Ahmad Shah]. Tehran: Erfan. [in Persian]##Hosseini Qomi, Q. A. ibn S. al-D. H. (2005). Kholasat al-Tavarikh [Summary of histories]. Tehran: University of Tehran Press. [in Persian]##Hosseini, K. ibn Q. (2000). Tarikh-e Ilchi Nezamshah [The history of the Ilchi Nezamshah]. Tehran: The Society of Cultural Works and Luminaries. [in Persian]##Ibn al-Athir, I. al-D. A. al-H. (1965). Al-Kamil fi al-Tarikh [The complete history]. Beirut: Dar Sadir. [in Arabic]##Ibn Faqih, A. ibn M. (1996). Al-Buldan [The book of lands] (H. Yusef, Ed.). Beirut: Alam al-Kutub. [in Arabic]##Ibn Hawqal, A. al-Q. M. (1939). Surat al-Ardh [The face of the earth] (J. H. Kramers, Ed.). Leiden: Brill. [in Arabic]##Ibn Khordadbeh, A. al-Q. U. A. (1889). Al-Masalik wa al-Mamalik [Routes and kingdoms] (De Goeje, Ed.). Leiden: Brill. [in Arabic]
Ibn Rusta, A. ibn U. (1891). Al-Alaq al-Nafisa [The precious connections] (De Goeje, Ed.). Leiden: Brill. [in Arabic]##Istakhri, I. ibn M. (1927). Al-Masalik wa al-Mamalik [Routes and kingdoms]. Leiden: Brill. [in Arabic]##Janabadi, M. B. (1999). Rowzat al-Safaviyyah [The safavid garden]. Tehran: Mahmoud Afshar Foundation. [in Persian]##Jeyhani, A. al-Q. ibn A. (1989). Ashkal al-Alam [The Forms of the World] (A. ibn A. S. Kateb, Trans.). Mashhad: Beh Nashr. [in Persian]##Jovayni, A. al-D. A.-M. (1937). Tarikh-e Jahan-Gusha [The history of the world conqueror]. Leiden: Brill. [in Persian]
Khalifeh ibn Khayyat, A. O. (1995). Tarikh [The History] (N. Fawaz, Ed.). Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyyah. [in Arabic]##Khavari Shirazi, M. F. (2001). Tarikh-e Zulqarnain [The History of Zulqarnain]. Tehran: Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance. [in Persian]##Khavari, A. (1983). Zahabiyeh: Tasavof-e Elmi - Asar-e Adabi [The Zahabiyeh: Scientific Sufism - Literary Works]. Tehran: University of Tehran. [in Persian]##Khwandamir, G. al-D. (1983). Tarikh-e Habib al-Siyar fi Akhbar-e Afrad-e Bashar [The history of the beloved of biographies in the accounts of humans]. Tehran: Khayyam. [in Persian]##Labaf Khaniki, R. A. (2009). Qanat, Origin and Sustenance of Gonabad and Kohestan. Paj, 2(5), 165–172. [in Persian]##Le Strange, G. (2004). Geography of the Eastern Caliphate (M. Erfan, Trans.). Tehran: Elmi va Farhangi. [in Persian]##Maqdisi, A. A. M. (1991). Ahsan al-Taqasim fi Ma'rifat al-Aqalim [The best divisions in the knowledge of regions]. Cairo: Maktabat Madbuli. [in Arabic]##Marco Polo (1984). Safarhay-e Marco Polo [The travels of Marco Polo] (R. Golbang, Trans.). Tehran: Koushesh. [in Persian]##Marvi, M. K. (1985). Alam Ara-ye Naderi [The history of Nader Shah]. Tehran: Zavvar. [in Persian]##Mashkoor, M. J. (1966). Fehrest-e bana-ha-ye tarikhi va amaken-e bastani-ye Iran [A list of historical buildings and ancient sites of Iran]. Tehran: Donyaye Ketab. [in Persian]##Minhaj-e Siraj, A. O. O. (1984). Tabaqat-e Naseri [The Naseri classes] (A. Habibi, Ed.). Tehran: Donyaye Ketab. [in Persian]##Mir Khvand, M. ibn K. S. (1853). Rowzat al-Safa [The garden of purity]. Tehran: Dar al-Taba'a Khasseh Jadideh. [in Persian]##Mirnia, S. A. (1990). Ilha va Tayefeh-ha-ye Ashayeri-ye Khorasan [Tribes and Nomadic Groups of Khorasan]. Mashhad: Danesh. [in Persian]
Mohammad ibn Ebrahim (1964). Seljukian va Ghaz dar Kerman [The Seljuks and the Ghaz Tribes in Kerman]. Tehran: Nashr-e Elm. [in Persian]##Mohammad ibn Najib Bakran (1963). Jahannameh [The Worldbook]. Tehran: Ibn Sina. [in Persian]##Mohammadi Khomak, J. (1999). "Nakha'i-ha va Laluyi-ha che Kasani Hastiand?" [Who Are the Nakha'i and Laluyi Tribes?]. Matikan-e Sistan [Collection of Articles on Sistan Studies]. Mashhad: Vajiran. [in Persian]##Mojtahed-Zadeh, P. (2008). The Amirs of the Borderlands: And Eastern Iranian Borders (H. M. M. Nouri, Trans.). Tehran: Shirazeh.##Mostowfi Bafqi, M. M. (2006). Jame'-e Mofidi [The Comprehensive Book by Mofid]. Tehran: Asatir. [in Persian]
Naderi, B. (1980). Masjed-e Jame'-e Qa'en [The Jameh Mosque of Qa'en]. Asar Journal, 1(1), 103–107. [in Persian]##Na'ini, M. J. (1974). Jame'-e Ja'fari [The Comprehensive Book of Ja'fari] (I. Afshar, Ed.). Tehran: Society for National Monuments. [in Persian]##Nasavi, M. (2005). Seerat-e Jalal al-Din Mankoberni [The Biography of Jalal al-Din Mankoberni] (M. Minovi, Ed.). Tehran: Elmi va Farhangi. [in Persian]##Nashriyeh Asami-ye Anasir va Vahad-ha-ye Taqsimat-e Keshvari [Newsletter of the names of elements and units of territorial divisions] (2014). Tehran: Ministry of Interior, Office of Territorial Divisions. [in Persian]##Nasir Khusraw, A. M. H. al-D. Q. (1965). Safarnameh [The travelogue] (M. Dabirsiaghi, Ed.). Tehran: Tahuri. [in Persian]##Pazouki-Toroudi, N., & Shadmehr, A. (2005). Asar-e Sabt Shode-ye Iran dar Fehrest-e Asar-e Melli [Iranian cultural heritage sites registered on the National Heritage List]. Tehran: Cultural Heritage Organization. [in Persian]##Qashani, A. al-Q. A. ibn M. (1969). Tarikh-e Oljaito [The history of Oljaitu]. Tehran: Bongah Tarjomeh va Nashr Ketab. [in Persian]##Qatqan, M. Y. ibn A. (2006). Moskhar al-Bilad [The conqueror of lands]. Tehran: Mirath-e Maktoub. [in Persian]##Qodameh, ibn J. K. B. (1981). Al-Kharaj wa San’at al-Kitabah [Land tax and the craft of writing]. Baghdad: Dar al-Rashid. [in Arabic]##Qomi, H. ibn M. (2006). Tarikh-e Qom [The history of Qom] (H. ibn A. Qomi, Trans.). Qom: Marashi Najafi Library. [in Persian]##Rajabi, N. (2005). Tarikh va Joghrafiya-ye Shahrestan-e Qainat [History and geography of Qainat County]. Tehran: Shahrasub. [in Persian]##Rashid al-Din Fazlollah (1940). Tarikh-e Mobarak Ghazani [The blessed history of Ghazan]. Hertford: Stephen. [in Persian]##Rashid al-Din Fazlollah (1994). Jame al-Tawarikh [The compendium of histories]. Tehran: Mirath-e Maktoub. [in Persian]##Razi, A. A. (1961). Haft Eqlim [The Seven Climes]. Tehran: Elmi. [in Persian]##Razmara, H. A. (1950). Farhang-e Joghrafiya-ye Iran (Abadiha) [A geographical dictionary of Iran: Settlements], Vol. 9. Tehran: Army Printing House. [in Persian]##Razpoosh, S. (1998). Banou Simjur. Encyclopaedia of the Islamic World, Vol. 4. Tehran: Foundation for the Islamic Encyclopaedia. [in Persian]##Saeedzadeh, M. (1992). Da'erat al-Ma'aref-e Qa'en [Encyclopedia of Qa’en]. Qom: Without Publisher. [in Persian]##Safa, A. (1994). Tarikh-e Jiroft va Kahnooj [History of Jiroft and Kahnooj]. Kerman: Kerman Studies Center. [in Persian]##Sam Khaniyani, A. A., Barzegar, K., Zarei, A., & Mahmoudi-Nasab, A. A. (2023). Mo'arrefi va tahlil-e ketibeh-ha-ye masjed-e jame-e Qa’en [Introduction and analysis of the inscriptions of Qa’en’s Jame Mosque]. Farhang-Social Studies of Khorasan, 18(2), 53–94. [in Persian]##Sam’ani, A. al-K. ibn M. (1962). Al-Ansab [The genealogies] (A. al-M. al-Yamani, Ed.). Hyderabad: Da'erat al-Ma'aref al-Othmaniyyah. [in Arabic]##Samarqandi, K. al-D. A. al-R. (2004). Matla' al-Sa'dain va Majma' al-Bahrain [The rise of two auspicious stars and the confluence of two seas]. Tehran: Research Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies. [in Persian]##Shabankareh’i, M. ibn A. (2002). Majma’ al-Ansab [The compendium of genealogies]. Tehran: Amir Kabir. [in Persian]##Shahrestan-ha-ye Iranshahr, a Middle Persian Text (2009). Edited by T. Daryaee; Translated by S. Jalilian. Tehran: Toos. [Persian trans.]##Shirvani, Z. al-A. (1936). Bostan al-Siyahah [The garden of travels]. Tehran: Ketabkhaneh-ye Sanaei. [in Persian]##Sistani, M. S. H. ibn M. G. al-D. (2004). Ehya al-Molouk: Tarikh-e Sistan ta Asr-e Safavi [Revival of Kings: History of Sistan until the Safavid Era]. Tehran: Elmi va Farhangi. [in Persian]##Smith, E. (1876). The Perso-Afghan Mission, 1871–72. Eastern Persia: An Account of the Journeys of the Persian Boundary Commission, Vol. 1. London: Macmillan and Co.##Sobki, T. al-D. A. N. A. al-W. ibn A. (1963). Tabaqat al-Shafi'iyyah al-Kubra [The major classes of the Shafi'is] (M. M. al-Tanahi & A. M. al-Halou, Eds.). Cairo: Dar Ihya al-Kutub al-Arabiyyah. [in Arabic]##Soltani, S. (2008). Jostari dar Bazshenasi-ye Qala'eh-ye Kohestan [A study on recognizing the fortresses of Kohestan]. Birjand: Cultural Heritage Organization. [in Persian]##Tabari, M. ibn J. (1967). Tarikh al-Umam wa al-Muluk [The history of nations and kings]. Beirut: Dar al-Turath. [in Arabic]##Tarikh-e Qizilbashan [The history of the Qizilbash] (1982). Tehran: Behnam. [in Persian]##Tarikh-e Sistan [The history of Sistan] (1987). Tehran: Padideh-e Khavar. [in Persian]##Tattavi, Q. A., & Qazvini, A. K. (2003). Tarikh-e Alfi [The millennium history]. Tehran: Elmi va Farhangi. [in Persian]##Tehrani, M. S. (2004). Mirat-e Varidat [The mirror of inspirations]. Tehran: Mirath-e Maktoub. [in Persian]##Utbi, M. ibn A. (2005). Tarikh-e Yamini [The Yamini history] (Jarafadaghani, Trans.). Tehran: Elmi va Farhangi. [in Persian]##Ya'qubi, A. ibn I. (2001). Al-Buldan [The countries]. Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyyah. [in Arabic]##Yaqut al-Hamawi, A. A. (1995). Mu'jam al-Buldan [The dictionary of countries]. Beirut: Dar Sadir. [in Arabic]##Yazdi, S. al-D. A. (2008). Zafarnameh [The book of victories]. (S. S. Mir Mohammadsadeq & A. Navaei, Eds.). Tehran: Islamic Parliament. [in Persian]##Zahiri Nishapuri, Z. al-D. (1953). Seljuknameh [The book of the Seljuks]. Tehran: Kalaleh Khavar. [in Persian]##Zamchi Esfazari, M. al-D. M. (1959). Rauzat al-Jannat fi Awsaf-e Madinat Herat [Gardens of paradise in the description of the City of Herat]. Tehran: University of Tehran. [in Persian]##

  • Receive Date 22 November 2024
  • Revise Date 02 January 2025
  • Accept Date 18 January 2025