Journal of Socio-Cultural Studies of Khorasan

Journal of Socio-Cultural Studies of Khorasan

The Role of Job Motivation in Shaping Innovative Behavior: The Mediating Role of Job Enthusiasm Among Elementary School Teachers in Birjand

Authors
1 Associate Professor, Department of Educational Sciences, Faculty of Educational Sciences and Psychology, University of Birjand, Iran (Corresponding author),
2 MA Graduate in Educational Management, Department of Educational Sciences, Faculty of Educational Sciences and Psychology, University of Birjand, Iran
Abstract
 Introduction
The need for education, fostering creativity, and encouraging innovative thinking and behavior is crucial for building a prosperous society. This is particularly significant in primary education, as it plays a formative role in students’ cognitive, biological and social development. Primary education also serves as a vehicle for passing on beliefs, ethics, customs, values, and skills to the next generation, while creating an environment conducive to the growth of students’ innate talents and abilities. As a result, these talents and academic performance can flourish. In this context, some researchers suggest that an organization’s focus on creating a motivating environment can foster innovative behavior. Motivated employees tend to exhibit more innovative behaviors because they approach their tasks with greater passion and commitment, pay closer attention to creative responsibilities, and develop stronger emotional connections to their work. Therefore, job motivation is one variable that appears to influence teachers' innovative behavior. However, a key question arises: Is this relationship direct, or is it mediated by other factors? Given the impact that job motivation can have on an organization, it seems plausible that job motivation may influence teachers’ innovative behavior through its effect on job enthusiasm. Hence, this study examines the role of job motivation in promoting innovative behavior, with a focus on the mediating role of job enthusiasm among primary education teachers in Birjand.
Methodology
This research employs a quantitative, applied and correlational methodology. The statistical population consists of all elementary school teachers in Birjand during the 2011-2012 academic year (900 teachers). Based on the Morgan and Krejcie’s (1970) table, 270 participants were selected as the research sample using a multi-stage cluster sampling method. First, Birjand was divided into three districts: North, South and Central. Schools were randomly selected from each district, and all teachers from the selected schools participated in the study. To account for possible sample attrition, the final sample size was set at 280 participants, with a significance level of 0.01. Data collection instruments included Kanter’s (1988) Innovative Behavior Questionnaire, Herzberg’s (1966) Job Motivation Questionnaire, and Salanova and Schaufeli’s (2001) Job Enthusiasm Questionnaire. Kanter’s Innovative Behavior Questionnaire comprises eight questions, scored on a five-point Likert scale ranging from completely disagree to completely agree. The minimum possible score is 8, and the maximum is 40, with higher scores indicating greater innovative behavior. Herzberg’s Job Motivation Questionnaire consists of 40 items, also scored on a five-point Likert scale from completely disagree to completely agree. Scores between 40 and 80 indicate weak motivation, scores between 80 and 160 reflect moderate motivation, and scores above 160 indicate strong motivation. Salanova and Schaufeli’s Job Enthusiasm Questionnaire includes 17 questions, divided into three dimensions: Vigor (questions 1–6), Dedication (questions 7–11), and Absorption (questions 12–17). This questionnaire is also scored on a five-point Likert scale, with scores ranging from 1 (completely disagree) to 5 (completely agree). The total score ranges from 17 to 85, with higher scores representing higher levels of job enthusiasm. The reliability of the questionnaires in this study was 0.92, 0.86 and 0.89, respectively. Data were analyzed using statistical regression tests and path analysis, with a significance level of 0.05.
 
Findings
The results revealed a positive and significant relationship between job motivation and job enthusiasm, as well as between job enthusiasm and innovative behavior. Specifically, increased job motivation leads to higher levels of job enthusiasm, which in turn promotes innovative behavior. The Sobel test confirmed that job enthusiasm mediates the relationship between job motivation and innovative behavior among elementary school teachers in Birjand. The indirect effect of job motivation on innovative behavior through enthusiasm was 0.49, and this relationship was positive. In other words, as job motivation increases, job enthusiasm also rises, resulting in higher levels of innovative behavior.
Conclusion
Based on the findings of this research, it can be concluded that job motivation comprises a set of internal and external forces that initiate work-related behaviors and determine their form, direction, intensity, and persistence. Career motivation drives individuals to perform tasks or behaviors, and the higher a teacher's job motivation, the more effective and creative they can be in the classroom. Therefore, job motivation can serve as a catalyst for change within organizations, particularly in educational institutions, by fostering job enthusiasm and promoting innovative behavior among teachers. To enhance this dynamic, it is recommended that teachers be encouraged and recognized for their ideas and contributions. A well-designed performance evaluation and reward system can boost motivation and enthusiasm, leading to greater creativity and innovation in the workplace.
Keywords

Subjects


References
Allen, T. D. & Rush, M. C. (1998). The effects of organizational citizenship behavior on performance judgments: A field study and a laboratory experiment. Journal of Applied Psychology, 83, 247–260.
Bahmanyar, S. (1402). Naghsh vaseteh-ye yādgiri mādam-ol-omr dar rabate farhang-e sāzmāni va raftār-e novāvarāne dar moallemān-e madāres-e ebtādā’ī-ye shahrestān-e zirkuh. [The mediating role of lifelong learning in the relationship between organizational culture and innovative behavior among elementary school teachers in Zirkouh County]. Journal of Psychology and Educational Sciences in the Third Millennium, 23(3), 418-438. [In Persian]
Batmani, S. (2019). Olgooy-e rabt-ha-ye niyazha-ye bonyadi va raftar novāvarāne mo'aleman ba naqsh vāsitegarī angizeh daruni va khodkārāmdī shoghli [The model of relationships between basic needs and innovative behavior of teachers with the mediating role of intrinsic motivation and job self-efficacy.]. (Unpublished master’s thesis). Payam Noor University, Kermanshah Center, Kermanshah, Iran. [In Persian]
Cho, K.H. Lee, S. H. (2007). Commitment to gender policy, commitment to organization and innovative behavior: some unexpected linkages in Korea. International Journal of Public Administration, 30(12), 1485-1502.
Deressa, A & Zeru, G (2019). Work motivation and its effects on organizational performance: the case of nurses in Hawassa public and private hospitals: Mixed method study approach. Deressa and Zeru BMC Res Note, 213(12), 1-6.
Emami, H. (2017). Barresi-ye rabete-ye eshteyagh-e shoghli va raftar-e noavarane ba nakshe miyanji gorayesh-e kar afarini dar miyan honaramoozan-e honarestanha-ye fani va herfei shahrestan-e Kermanshah dar sal 1396-1397. [Investigating the relationship between job engagement and innovative behavior with the mediating role of entrepreneurial orientation among technical and vocational school instructors in Kermanshah during the years 2017-2018]. (Unpublished master’s thesis), Razi University, Kermanshah, Iran. [In Persian]
Falahi, A., & Abdi., (2019). Barresi-ye rabete-ye talogh-khatr-e kari ba raftar-e noavarane moaleman maghate ebtedaie shahrestan-e Nurabad Lorestan dar sal-e tahsili 97-98. [Examining the relationship between work engagement and innovative behavior of elementary school teachers in Nurabad, Lorestan, during the 2018-2019 academic year]. The Second National Conference on New Findings of Teaching-Learning in Elementary School. Bandar Abbas. [In Persian]
Faryad, L., Doharian, A., & Nazimi, Sh., (2015). Barresi-ye asar-e tavanmandsaazi-ye ravanshenakht bar raftar-e noavarane karkonan ba tavajoh be eshtiyagh-e shoghli-ye anan [Examining the effect of psychological empowerment on the innovative behavior of employees, considering their job engagement]. Journal of Development and Transformation Management, 3(25), 17-26. [In Persian]
Forson, P. Dramani, J. B. Frimpong, P. B. Arthur, E. & Mahawiya, S. (2021). Effect of oil price volatility on the trade balance in subSaharan Africa. OPEC Energy Review, 46(3), 340-361.
Heydari, M., Farrokhi, F., & Ghorbani Dolat-Abadi, M., (2015). Barresi-ye rabete-ye adalat-e sazmani, eshteyagh-e shoghli va taahhod-e sazmani azai-ye hey’at-e elmi-ye daneshgah-e Esfahan [Examining the relationship between organizational justice, job engagement, and organizational commitment among the faculty members of University of Isfahan]. Journal of Educational Management Innovations, 1(2), 21-36. [In Persian]
Kaab-Umir, N., Azizieh, R., & Khalafi, A., (2019). Tarrahi va azmoondan-e olgu-i az ba'zi pishayandha-ye angizeh-e shoghli dar karkonan-e sherkat-e behrehbardari-ye naft va gaz-e Marun. [Designing and testing a model of certain antecedents of job motivation among the employees of Marun Oil and Gas Exploitation Company]. Career and Organizational Counseling Quarterly, 43(12), 113-132. [In Persian]
Kiyani, I., & Mohammadi Bardbari, S., (2019). Angizeh shoghli va tark-e khedmat karkonan (mord-e motale'eh bank-e melli shahrekord). [Job motivation and employee turnover: A case study of Bank Melli in Shahrekord]. The 7th National Conference of Modern Studies and Researches in the Field of Human Sciences, Management and Entrepreneurship of Iran, Tehran. [In Persian]
Khaledi Sardashti., (2019). Noavari dar modiriat amuzeshi madars.[Innovation in educational management of schools]. Tehran: Zarnevesht. [In Persian]
Khosravi, H., Pourshafei, H., & Taherpour, F., (1402). Tabin-e naghshe khoshbini va sarzendegi dar raftar-e novavarane-ye moaleman-e dore-ye ebtedayi ba miyanji-gari-e enetafpaziry. [Explaining the role of optimism and vitality in the innovative behavior of elementary school teachers, with the mediating role of flexibility.]. Journal of Education, 153(4), 91-108. [In Persian]
Makvandi, M., (1400). Barrasi-ye didgah-e moaleman dar raabteh ba moskaleh-haye ejrayi-ye tarh-e arzeshyabi-ye keyfiyat tosifi dar maghta-ye ebtedayi va era'ye-ye rahkarhayi baraye bartaraf kardan-e anha. [Examining teachers’ perspectives on the implementation challenges of the qualitative descriptive evaluation plan in elementary schools and providing solutions to address them.].  Journal of Research in Islamic Education and Training, 51(29), 213-236. [In Persian]
Nadaf, M., Mehrabi, A., & Salarond, J., (2018). Tabadol-e ejtema'i-ye sazman va raftar-e kari-ye novavarane: Takid bar naghshe miyanji-e eshteyagh-e shoghli [Organizational social exchange and innovative work behavior: Emphasizing the mediating role of job engagement]. Journal of Innovation Management in Defense Organizations, 3(2), 129-154. [In Persian]
Nasiri Valikbani, F., Ghatlash, A., & Sarjahani, Z., (2014). Raabteh-e tavanemadsazi-ye karkonan ba amalkard-e shoghli va bahrehvari-ye niroo-ye ensani-ye sazman-e amuzesh va parvaresh-e ostan-e Fars. [The relationship between employee empowerment and job performance and the productivity of the workforce in the department of education of Fars Province]. Organizational Training Management Quarterly, 4(2), 63-90. [In Persian]
Niazi, M., (2019). Barrasi-ye raabteh beyn-e sarmay-e ravanshenakht, angizesh shoghli va ta'ahhod kari ba eshteyagh shoghli moaleman shahrestan Badreh [Examining the relationship between psychological capital, job motivation, and work commitment with job engagement among teachers in Badreh County] (Unpublished master’s thesis), Islamic Azad University of Ilam, Iran. [In Persian]
Qenai, A., & Hemmati, A., (2019). Noavari dar sazman [Innovation in the organization]. Tehran: Novaran Danesh. [In Persian]
Rezaei, Z., (2019). Osol amuzesh va parvarsh ebtedayi. [Principles of elementary education]. Tehran: Bid. [In Persian]
Riyanto,S, Endri, E & Herlisha, N. (2021). Effect of work motivation and job satisfaction on employee performance: Mediating role of employee engagement. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 19(3), 162-174.
Sadeghi Deh Cheshmeh, M., Qaedamini Harooni, A., & Maleki Farsani, Gh. (2020). Asarat-e rahbari-e tahvoli-ye va tabadoli bar raftar-e novavarane ba naghshe ta'dilgar-e tavanemandsazi-e ravan-shenakht [The effects of transformational and transactional leadership on innovative behavior, with the moderating role of psychological empowerment]. Journal of Cultural Leadership Studies, 1(3), 36-62. [In Persian]
Safi, A., (2017). Amuzesh ve parvarsh ebtedai, rahnamay-e tahsili ve motevaseteh. [Elementary, guidance, and secondary education]. Tehran: SAMT. [In Persian]
Shabani Bahar, G., & Sharbati, N., (2017). Rabteh bein angizeha-ye shoghli karkonan va novavari sazmani edarat-e varzesh va javānān-e ostān-e Hamadān [The relationship between employee job motivations and organizational innovation in the sports and youth offices of Hamadan Province]. Survey in Teaching Humanities, 3(4), 111-121. [In Persian]
Shabani, Z., Ghanbaripanah, M., & Yarmoradi, F., (2023). Pishbini ta'ahhod-e herfei bar asas-e khodkaraamadi va raftar-e noavarane moaleman-e madares-e estesnaie Lorestan [Predicting professional commitment based on self-efficacy and innovative behavior of teachers in exceptional schools of Lorestan]. Sport Physiology and Management Investigations, 31(8), 117-140. [In Persian]
Shokri Baghi, M., & Mousavirad, T., (2018). Barresi-ye naghsh-e angizeh-e shoghli dar talloq-khatr kāri dar dabīrān-e tarbiyat-e badani-ye shahr-e Mashhad. [Examining the role of job motivation in work engagement among physical education teachers in the city of Mashhad]. National Conference on Physical Education, Nutrition and Sports Medicine, University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad. [In Persian]
Soltani Arabshahi, K., Sohrabi, Z., Keshavarzi, M., & Ramezani, Gh., (2018). Barresiye rabete abaad-e angizesh khodtadyil-gari ba eshtiaq shoghli azaa-ye heyat-e elmi daneshgah-e ulum-e pezeshki-ye Iran [Investigation of the relationship between dimensions of self-determination motivation and job enthusiasm among faculty members of Iran University of Medical Sciences]. Journal of Education Development in Medical Sciences, 33(12), 21-32. [In Persian]
Yekta, M., & Heidari, S., (2020) Tajrobeh zisteh moalleman madares ghairentefaei shahre esfahan az moshkelaat danesh-amoozan maghat’e ebtedayi dar kelas-haye bar khat dar doreh shiu'e virus-e corona [Living experiences of teachers in non-profit schools of Isfahan city regarding the problems of elementary school students in online classes during the COVID-19 pandemic]. Journal of Applied Educational Leadership, 2(3), 23-30. [In Persian]
Zarei Nasab, A., (2018). Barresi tasir-e eshtiyagh-e shoghli va zarfiat jazb danesh bar raftar novavarane ba naghh miyanji be eshterakgozari khatahaye sazman-i (mord-e motale'eh: sherkat ab va fazalab roostayi va shahri ostan-e Ilam) [An investigation into the impact of job passion and knowledge absorption capacity on innovative behavior with organizational error sharing as a mediating role: A case study of rural and urban water and wastewater company of Ilam province], (Unpublished master’s thesis), Ilam University, Iran. [In Persian]
 

  • Receive Date 13 April 2024
  • Revise Date 03 September 2024
  • Accept Date 28 September 2024