Journal of Socio-Cultural Studies of Khorasan

Journal of Socio-Cultural Studies of Khorasan

Ranking the Capacities for Creating Economic Prosperity in Region 9 of Land Use Planning

Authors
1 Assistant Professor of Economics, Faculty of Social and Behavioral Sciences, Ahlul Bayt International University, Iran, (Corresponding Author)
2 Assistant Professor of Economics, Faculty of Social and Behavioral Sciences, Ahlul Bayt International University, Iran,
3 MA Student of Economics, Faculty of Social and Behavioral Sciences, Ahlul Bayt International University, Iran abdulbasir.
Abstract
Introduction
Assessing the capacity to foster economic prosperity is a critical and constructive factor for planning and implementing any government’s long-term strategies within a region or society. Without an accurate evaluation of economic prosperity, governments and economic policymakers may encounter epistemological challenges within their economic communities. Therefore, a comprehensive understanding of a region’s economic prosperity is essential for policy planning. Regions and villages serve as the primary levels of management and are the main implementers of government policies. In today’s world, the regional economy plays a significant role in management and development planning. The regional economy comprises various sectors, each possessing different capacities and capabilities. For regional development and national development planning, it is imperative not to make assumptions about investment, production, and employment being constant across all sectors. Optimal allocation of production facilities and resources requires consideration of regional potentials and capabilities in the production of goods and services in all national development plans. This approach can potentially increase the share of economic sectors in national production. Therefore, identifying drivers to create economic prosperity in the 9th region of land use planning is considered an important strategy for implementing economic development growth policies. Given the importance of this subject, this research aims to measure the capacity for creating economic prosperity in the 9th district using a multi-criteria decision-making method. The research seeks to assess which cities have a higher capacity and potential for creating economic prosperity in the 9th region. It also aims to determine the importance coefficient of different economic sectors from experts’ perspectives. The results indicate that agriculture, mining, services, and industry are highly significant in the region for economic prosperity.
Methods
The main objective of this study is to identify the drivers of economic prosperity among large cities (region 9 of land use planning) based on a multi-criteria decision-making model. This study is applied in terms of its objectives. The data collection methodology is based on library and documentary data, as well as questionnaires. The output from these questionnaires has been processed using Expert Choice software. The research approach is descriptive-analytical. The data used in this research are obtained from the Statistical Center of Iran. The study’s statistical population encompasses nine regions (South, North, and Razavi) and 52 counties within these regions. The research aims to rank these nine regions and 52 counties using the TOPSIS model and hierarchical analysis. The methodology for implementing this ranking process is detailed in the following sections.
 
Findings
The findings from the TOPSIS (AHP) model, based on the insights of twelve experts in the field of economic sciences and planning, indicate that the agriculture index, with a weight of 0.421, is ranked first. This is followed by the mining index with a weight of 0.277 in second place, and the service index with a weight of 0.157 in third place. The industry index, with a weight of 0.145, is positioned last. When excluding the added value of oil and gas, the cities are ranked as follows: Mashhad leads with a score of 0.593, followed by Khaf with a score of 0.463, and Zirkuh with a score of 0.414, placing them in first, second, and third places respectively. Conversely, the cities of Salehabad (score: 0.014), Sheshtamad (score: 0.002), and Kuhsorkh (score: 0.001) are ranked at the bottom.
 
Conclusion
This study aims to rank the potential for economic prosperity in the ninth region of Iran’s land use planning. The ranking is based on a multi-criteria decision-making model, utilizing four sub-economic indices from the country’s national accounts in 2020. These economic sub-indices are categorized into four sectors: agriculture, industry, mining, and services. The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) model was employed to weight these indices and determine their significance. Through pairwise comparison of the four indices and assigning weights based on expert opinions, it was determined that the agriculture sector received the highest weight of 0.421, followed by mining with a weight of 0.277. The service sector was assigned a lower weight of 0.157, while the industry sector received the lowest weight of 0.145.
Keywords

Subjects


References
- Abdoli, G., Kardgar, R., kazemi, A., & Molaei Qelichi, M. (2017). Rotbe-bandi-ye ostān-hā-ye keshvar az nazar-e ijād-e arzesh-afzode-ye zir bakhsh-hā-ye eqtesādi bar asās-e model-e tasamim-giri-ye chand māyāri [Ranking the Iran’s provinces based on added value in the economic subsectors by means of multi-criteria decision-making models (VIKOR)]. Regional Planning7(26), 1-14. [In Persian]
- Bakhtiari, S., & Dehghanzadeh, M. (2012). Naqsh-e fa’aliyat-haye san’ati dar tose’e-ye eqtesadi rahyaft-e model-e dadeh - setandeh (manateq-e shahri) [The role of industrial activities in the economic development of the data-output model approach (urban areas)]. Planning and Budgeting, 18(2), 59-79. [In Persian]
- Bettencort, M. (2010). Financial development and economic growth in Latin America: Is Schumpeter right? Journal of Policy Modeling, 34(12), 458-475.
- Castro, V. (2012). The duration of Economic expansions and recessions: more than duration dependence. Journal of Macroeconomics, 32(20), 347-365.
- Durrani, R., & Barati, J. (2013). Naqsh-e san’at-e gardeshgari dar ijad-e eshteghal dar ostan-e Razavi” [The role of tourism industry in creating employment in Razavi province]. Tourism Management Studies, 8(25), 109-134. [In Persian]
- Ezri, M., & Faghani, F. (1392). Karbord-e AHP va Tapsis jahat-e olaviyat-bandi-ye avamel-e moaser bar boruz-e fesad-e edari va rahkarha-ye moqabele ba an [AHP and Topsis for prioritizing factors and strategies to combat administrative corruption]. Journal of Applied Mathematics, 10(1), 43-57. [In Persian]
- Farjirad, K., & Kazemian, G. (2016). Tahlil-e fazāyi-e avāmel-e ejtemāi va farhangi-e pishrān va māne’ āmāyesh va tose’eh-ye mantaghe’i dar ostān-e khorāsān-e shomāli [Spatial analysis of social and cultural factors driving and hindering regional development in North Khorasan province]. Applied Sociology, 28(4), 155-172. [In Persian]
- Gao, Y., Zheng, Y., Hu, A., & Meng, G. (2015). Input-Output-Based Genuine Value Added and Genuine Productivity in China’s Industrial Sectors (1995-2010), Institute of Development Economics. Proceedings of the German Development Economics Conference, 2(13), 132-151.
- Habibi Nasab, S. M. I., Mugheri, H., & Baskha, M. (2011). Avāmel-e mo’asser bar arzesh-afzude-ye kārgāh-hā-ye san’ati bā dah nafar kārkon va bishtar [Factors affecting the added value of industrial workshops with ten workers and more]. Economic Research, 92(45), 47-64. [In Persian]
- Javanshiri, M., Namdarzadeh, M., & Nabiuni, S. (1400). Shenāsāyi va tahlil-e pishrān-hā-ye kelidi moaser bar tahaghoghpaziri-ye tarhā-ye āmāyesh-e sarzamin: Motāle’at-e moredi-e ostān-e rezavi [Identification and analysis of key drivers affecting the realization of land improvement projects: A case study of Razavi province]. Geographical Studies of Arid Regions, 12(42), 62-87. [In Persian]
- Jafari Samimi, A., & Sadat Naqvi, S. (2007). Barrasi-e maziat-e nesbi-e arzesh-afzude- bakhsh-hā-ye eqtesādi dar mantagh bar asās-e amalkard-e barnāmeh-ye sevom-e tose’eh [Investigating the relative value-added advantage of economic sectors in the region based on the performance of the third development program]. Knowledge and Development, 15(23), 1-24. [In Persian]
- Mehnatfar, Y., Soleimani, H., & Babaei, S. (2014). Tāyid-e arzesh-afzude-ye bakhsh-hā-ye mokhtalef-e eqtesādi bar roshd-e eqtesādi-ye ostān-hā dar barnāmeh-ye chahārom-e tose’eh (bā tākid bar bakhsh-e keshāvari) bā estefāde az dāde-hā-ye tābloi
- [The verification of the value added of different economic sectors on the economic growth of provinces in the fourth development plan (with emphasis on the agricultural sector) using input-output data]. Research Journal of Macroeconomics, 10(20), 1-16. [In Persian]
- Khakpour, B. (2004). Barrasi-e vaz’iyat-e eqtesādi-ye navāhi-ye rustāyi va tāsir-e ān bar mohājerat-hā-ye rustāyi shahrestān-e shirvān [Investigation of the economic situation of rural areas and its effect on rural migrations of Shirvan city]. Geography and Regional Development, 2(4), 159-180. [In Persian]
- Khanifar, H. (2010). Darāmdi bar mafhum-e āmāyesh-e sarzamin va kārbordehā-ye ān dar irān [An introduction to the concept of land preparation and its applications in Iran]. Land Preparation Magazine, 2(2), 5-26. [In Persian]
- Mohammadzadeh, P., Beheshti, M. B., & Ghasemlou, K. (2017). Tahlil-e taghirāt-e sākhtāri va maziat-e raghābat-e bakhsh-hā-ye eqtesādi-ye shahrestān-hā-ye keshvar bā estefāde az model-e taghyir-e sehm-e poyāyi va fazāyi [Analysis of structural changes and competitive advantage of economic sectors in the counties of Iran using the dynamic and spatial shift-share model]. Economic Policies, 26(88), 71-106. [In Persian]
- Monchuk, D. C., Miraowski, J. A., & Hayes, D. J. (2007). An analysis of regional economic growth in the U.S. Midwest. Review of Agricultural Economics, 29(1), 17-39.
- Mousavi, M., & Kohki Sadat, F. (2015). Olaviat-senji-e shākhes-hā-ye tose’eh-ye irāni eslāmi dar tahaghogh-e āmāyesh-e sarzamin dar ostān-e khorāsān-e razavi (bā roikard-e adālat-mehvari) [Priority assessment of Iranian Islamic development indicators in the realization of spatial planning of Khorasan Razavi province with the justice-based approach]. Geography and Development, 14(45), 120-193. [In Persian]
Mousavi, M., Ghadri, R., Taghilo, A. A., & Sadat Kahaki, F. (2017). Tadvin-e senāriohā-ye tahaghogh-paziri-ye āmāyesh-e sarzamin: Motāl-e moredi-e ostān-e Khorasan-e Razavi) [Scenario development in feasibility of land-use planning: A case study of Razavi Khorasan]. Town and Country Planning, 10(1), 65-91. [In Persian]
- Najafi, A. A., Farhang Moghadam, B., Noorzaei, I., & Movahdi, F. (2015). Arzyābi-ye kami va entekhāb-e system-e behine-ye ejrā jahat-e projehā-ye āzādrāhi bā rooykarde AHP dar vezarat-e rāh va shahrsāzi [Assessing and choosing the best implementation system for highway projects using the AHP approach within the Ministry of Roads and Urban Development]. Journal of Transportation Research, 13(1), 88-100. [In Persian]
- Nicholas, A., Ghassen, M., Emmanuel, S., Ahdi, N. A., & Rangan, G. (2014). Dutch disease effect of oil rent on agriculture value added in middle east and north African (MENA) countries. Journal of Energy Economics, 45(3), 485-490.
- Odedokun, M. O. (1996). Alternative econometric approaches for analyzing the role of the financial sector in economic growth: Time-series evidence from LDCs. Journal of Development Economics, 50, 119-146.
- Omidvari, Z., & Moghdisi, R. (2018). Barāvord-e arzesh-afzode-ye belghove-ye zirbakhsh-hā-ye keshāvarzi: Moqāyese-ye rahyāft-hā-ye novin va marsoom) [Estimating the potential added value of agricultural subsectors: Comparing modern and conventional approaches]. Agricultural Economics and Development, 27(105), 171-204. [In Persian]
- Feshari, M. (2015). Avāmel-e moaser bar modat-zamān-e baqā-ye ronagh-e eqtesādi-ye keshvar-hā-ye montakhab-e sāzmān-e hamkāri-ye eslāmi: rahyāft-e tahlil-e baqā [Factors affecting the duration of economic prosperity in selected countries of the Irganization of Islamic Cooperation: A survival analysis approach]. Economic Modeling, 10(3), 97-120. [In Persian]
- Ramezani, S. M., Hajipour, M., & Behrouzi, M. (2013). Olovīat-bandi-ye bakhsh-hā-ye eqtesādi-ye ostān-e jonubi bā estefāde az farāyand-e tahlil-e selsele-marāteb [Prioritization of the economic sectors of South Province using the analytical hierarchy process (AHP)]. Economic Journal, 9(4), 55-82. [In Persian]
- Roland, G. (2016). Economic development (M. Soleimani, Trans.). Tehran: Ketab Naween. [In Persian]
- Sepehvand, F., & Naderi, M. (2019). Rāhkār-hā-ye tose’e-ye manātegh-e rostāyi dar shahrestān-e Nahāvand bā tākid bar motanavv’-sāzi-ye eqtesād [Strategies for the development of rural areas in Nahavand city with an emphasis on diversifying the economy]. Rural and Development Quarterly, 24(94), 1-32. [In Persian]
- Sakhai, E., Fahimifar, F., & Fahimifar, F. (2014). Pāyesh-e amalkard va rotbe-bandi-ye ostān-hā bar asās-e shākhes-hā-ye howze-ye vezarat-e omur-e eqtesādi va dārāyi [Monitoring the performance and ranking of the provinces based on the indicators of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Finance]. Economic Journal, 15(11-12), 5-26. [In Persian]
- Shakri, A. (2015). Eqtesād-e kalān, nazariye-hā va siāsat-hā [Macroeconomics, theories and policies]. Tehran: Rafe. [In Persian]
 
 
 
 
- Sadeghi Shahedani, M., & Ghafarifard, M. (2008). Barrasi-ye maziyat-hā-ye nesbi va tahlil-e pāzhuhesh-e sākhtāri-ye toli’d-e nākhāles-e dākheli dar shahrestān-hā-ye keshvar [“Analysis of comparative advantages and structural production of gross domestic product in the provinces of the country]. Economic Researches and Policies, 50(7), 115-136. [In Persian]
- Vosoughi, F. (1998). Mantaghe-bandi dar Iran [Zoning in Iran]. Geographical Research, 49(50), 25-46. [In Persian]
- Wang, R., Bing, X., Suocheng, D., Zehong, L., Duoxun, B., & Zhang, W. (2021). Research on the spatial differentiation and driving forces of eco-efficiency of regional tourism in China. Journal of Sustainability, 13(1), 259-280.
- Yazdanjoo, M., & Rabiei, M. (2015). Arzesh-afzode-ye eqtesādi va arzesh-afzode-ye bāzār [Economic added value and market added value]. [Paper Presentation]. The World Conference on Management, Economics, Accounting and Human Sciences. [In Persian].

  • Receive Date 14 December 2022
  • Revise Date 07 June 2023
  • Accept Date 16 July 2023