Journal of Socio-Cultural Studies of Khorasan

Journal of Socio-Cultural Studies of Khorasan

Analyzing the Ritual Superstructure of the Flagpole-Carrying Ceremony to Understand Collective Identity in Chesham Village

Authors
1 Assistant Professor of Anthropology, Hakim Sabzevari University, Sabzevar, Iran.
2 Ph.D. in Research of Art, Department of Research of Art, Alzahra University, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
 Introduction
Rituals serve as vessels for preserving and expressing a society’s historical, cultural, and religious memory, as well as its collective identity. Therefore, analyzing the structure and content of rituals is essential for understanding the various facets of a society’s identity. In Iran, particularly in the Razavi Khorasan province, rituals are diverse and complex, making research in this area crucial for recognizing national identity and protecting Iran’s intangible cultural heritage. Despite its importance, there is a significant gap in this field, especially in Razavi Khorasan. Previous studies have often overlooked the interdependence of rituals and their integration into broader collections or superstructures, which are vital for understanding collective identity. To address this gap, this research aims to describe and introduce the superstructure of the flagpole-carrying ritual in Chesham village, along with its other Muharram ritual superstructures, to recognize the collective identity of this ritual collection. By analyzing the structural system of the flagpole-carrying ritual, this study seeks to explore how the structural system of Chesham village’s Muharram ritual collection can be utilized to understand the collective identity of these rituals.
 
Method
This qualitative, descriptive-analytical research focuses on the flagpole-carrying ritual in Chesham village, located in Kah district, Davarzan county, in the western part of Razavi Khorasan province. Data collection primarily employed field methods and ethnography, supplemented by library research for theoretical and experimental literature. Field study tools included observation, semi-structured interviews, and open interviews. Data analysis utilized thematic analysis, a qualitative research approach based on analytical induction. This method involves “data classification and input and output data modeling” as a form of analytical typology (Mohammadpour, 2013, pp. 68-69). The thematic plan, as described by Wolcott (2005, 2008), was implemented in three stages: description, analysis, and interpretation (Mohammadpour, 2012, pp. 68-69). Initially, the collected data was organized in chronological order. In the analysis stage, data was categorized based on the ritual's placement within the ritual collection. Finally, in the interpretation stage, the ritual's placement within the regional ritual collection was compared and analyzed.
 
Findings
The flagpoles in Chesham village consist of 18 pieces, each with a wooden base and an iron Tuq on top. During the flagpole-carrying ritual, the bodies of the flagpoles are typically covered with black cloths, while the joint where the metal Tuq meets the body is adorned with colorful, often green scarves. This ritual is an integral part of the superstructure of flagpole-carrying and is connected to other superstructures that form the broader ritual collection of Chesham's Muharram rituals. In terms of timing and importance, flagpole-carrying holds a unique position in the village’s rituals. It is observed in four distinct periods: Friday nights of the first decade of Muharram, the eve of Ashura, Ashura morning, and Ashura evening. Flagpoles play a primary role in the flagpole-decorating and flagpole-carrying rituals, and a secondary role in various other rituals, including “Questions and Answers”, “Stone Beating”, “Nakhl Gardani”, “Ta’zieh”, and others. Moreover, flagpole-carrying itself encompasses a collection of rituals, including visiting the graves, and visitation letter reading; each with its own distinct characteristics and methods. Notably, the flagpole and flagpole-carrying rituals are symbols of the collective identity of the village people. They also play a significant role in shaping the collective identity of the ritual collection and the broader Muharram ritual superstructure in Chesham.
 
Discussion and Conclusion
Examining the structural system of Muharram rituals in Chesham village, particularly focusing on flagpole-carrying, highlights the significance of the narrative system in shaping the collective identity of this ritual tradition. In this narrative framework, both living and deceased actors utilize drama, words, music, and movement to convey the storytelling aspect of the rituals. This structural system, referred to as “superstructure” (Nünning & Rupp, 2013, p. 13), serves as a “block” within the broader “ritual grammar” of the Muharram ritual collection in Chesham, as well as in higher contexts across Khorasan and Iran. It comprises various subsystems, each representing different blocks that contribute to the overall structure. Each of these subsystems narrates the story by emphasizing specific performing methods, engaging the senses of the ritual actors, and incorporating their collective actions. A close examination of these narrative performance sequences within the superstructure of the Muharram rituals in Chesham, with a special focus on flagpole-carrying, demonstrates that the complexity and breadth of this superstructure—reflecting the community's collective identity—correspond to the peaks and troughs of the Ashura event narrative.
In summary, the social intermediary identity of the Alam in Chesham is manifested through the village's Muharram ritual collection, of which the Alam superstructure is an integral part. The collective identity associated with the flagpole-carrying superstructure can be discerned through three structural systems: ritual action, sensory action, and narrative performance (Figure 1). The foundation of this identity structure is the narration of the Ashura event throughout the calendar year, involving the participation of the entire village, as well as ritual objects such as a flag, palm tree, stone, chain, musical instruments, and ceremonial clothing.
Keywords

Subjects


Abbasi, F. Amin Khandaghi, J. (2021). Tahlil-e janbe-ye nemaaieshi-ye aeenhaa-ye Asb-e Chubi va Nakhlgardani-e Sabzavar az manzar-e Paul Woodruff.  [Analysis of the performative aspects of the wooden horse rituals and the palm-tree procession of Sabzevar from the perspective of Paul Woodruff]. Journal of research in arts and humanities, 6(36), 45-54. [In Persian].##Asad, T. (1993). Genealogies of religion: Discipline and reasons of power in Christianity and Islam. London: JHU Press.##Barabadi, A., & Shoaibi, Gh. & Homaee, M. & Validad, M. (2002).  Mardomshenaasi-e maraasem-e azaadaari-e Muharram dar shahrestaan-e Birjand [The anthropology of mourning ceremonies during the month of Muharram in Birjand]. Tehran: Qalam Ashena. [In Persian].##Bell, C. M. (1997). Ritual: Perspectives and dimensions. Oxford: Oxford University Press.##Bergesen, A. J. (1999). The ritual order. Humboldt Journal of Social Relations, 25, 157-197.##Beumer, M. (2020). The foundation of anthropology to ritual studies. Journal of Ritual Studies, 34(2), 20-30.##Geographic Organization of the Armed Forces. (2005). Farhang-e joghraafiaaee-ye aabaadiha-ye keshvar, ostaan-e Khorasan-e Razavi, shahrestaan-e Sabzevar. [Geographical dictionary of the settlements of the country, Razavi Khorasan province, Sabzevar county]. Tehran: Geographic Organization of the Armed Forces. [In Persian].##Fayaz, E. & Gharbi, M. (2016). Aaeen-e araakardan dar Sheshtamad-e Sabzavar. [The ritual of Arakardan in Sheshtomad, Sabzevar]. Culture and Folk Literature, 4(8), 1-24. [In Persian].##Gharbi, M (2020a). Aeen-e alambardaari-e Chesham [The flagpole-carrying ceremony in Chashem (A report on the registration dossier of intangible heritage)]. Mashhad: General Directorate of Cultural Heritage, Tourism, and Handicrafts of Razavi Khorasan (Unpublished research report) [In Persian].##Gharbi, M. (2020b). Maraasem-e soaal va javaab-e rouz-e ashura-ye Chasham-e shahrestaan-e Davarzan [The question-and-answer ceremony of Ashura in the village of Chashem, Davarzane County. Mashhad: General Directorate of Cultural Heritage, Tourism, and Handicrafts of Razavi Khorasan (Unpublished research report) [In Persian].##Grimes, R. (2004). Performance Theory and the Study of Ritual. In P. Antes, A. Geertz & R. Warne (Ed.), Volume 2 Textual, Comparative, Sociological, and Cognitive Approaches (pp. 109-138). Berlin, New York: De Gruyter.##Hamidi, S.& Shateri, M. (2016). Nakhlgardani-e Muharram dar Dorokhsh: Negaahi ensaanshenaakhti. [The carrying of palm branches during Muharram in Derakhshan: an anthropological perspective]. Journal of Socio-cultural Studies of Khorasan, 11(1), 85-103. [In Persian].##Malakotifar, V, & Gharbi, M. & Mousavi, M.H. (2018). Aeen-e nemaayesh-e shir dar Sheshtomad Sabzevar: Baaznemaaee-ye jahaanbini-haa va arzeshhaa-ye farhangi dar Aaeen. [The performance ritual of the lion in Sheshtomad, Sabzevar: representation of worldviews and cultural values in the ritual], Journal of dramatic Arts and Music, 9(17), 35-49. [In Persian].##Mireskandari, F., & Yazdani, R. (2020). Barresi-e mardomshenaakhti-e aaeen-e nakhlgardaani dar Jajarm-e Khorasan-e Shomaali [An anthropological study of the palm-swinging ritual in Jajarm, North Khorasan]. Culture of Iranian People, 62, 105-130. [In Persian]##Mohammadi, M. (2002). Farhang-e amaaken va joghrafia-ye tarikhi-ye Beihagh (Sabzavar) bar asaas-e Mojam al-Boldan-e Yaqut va taarikh-e Beihagh [The culture of places and the historical geography of Biheq (Sabzevar) based on Yaqut’s Mu'jam ul-Buldān and Tarikh-i Bayhaq]. Sabzavar: Azhand. [In Persian].##Mohammadpour, A. (2013). Ravesh-e tahghigh; zed-e ravesh (2) [Research Method; Anti-Method]. Tehran: Jamee Shenasan. [In Persian].##Statistical Centre of Iran (2016). Natayej-e sarshomaari-ye omumi-e nofus va maskan [The results of the general census of population and housing]. Retrieved on 11 August 2024, from: https://amar.org.ir/statistical-information/statid/52285 [In Persian].##Nünning, V., & Rupp, J. (2013). Ritual and narrative: An introduction. In Nünning, V., & Rupp, J. (Eds.), Ritual and narrative; Theoretical explorations and historical studies. Bielefeld: Transcript Verlag.##Rabbanikhah, M. (2011). Cheshmaan-e bidaar-e kavir, negaahi be taarikhche, zendegi va vasiatnaame-ye shohadaa-ye vaalaamaghaam-e rousta-ye Chesham [Awake eyes of the desert: A look at the history, life, and will of the esteemed martyrs of the Chasham village]. Sabzavar: Hakim Sabzevari University Press. [In Persian].##Rabbanikhah, M. (2019). Sabzavar, shahr-e aeenhaa-ye beshkuh. [Sabzevar: The city of magnificent rituals]. [Paper Presentation]. The Fourth Conference on New Perspectives in Folk Language and Literature. Mashhad, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad. [In Persian].##Rappaport, R. A. (1999). Ritual and Religion in the Making of Humanity (Vol. 110). Cambridge: Cambridge University.##Schechner, R. (1974). From ritual to theatre and back: The structure/process of the efficacy-entertainment dyad. Educational Theatre Journal, 26(4), 455-481.
Shateri, M (2012). Joghraafia-ye taarikhi va farhangi-ye Dorokhsh [Historical and cultural geography of Drakhsh]. Mashhad: Ketab-e Papoli. [In Persian].##Shateri, M. & Ashrafi, A. (2022). Sarkhong negin-e sabz-e kuhestaan [Redness of the Green Jewel of the Mountains]. Tehran: Ketab-e Shahr-e Elm. [In Persian].##Shateri, M. & Farzin, M. & Imantalab, K. (2013). Barresi-ye musiqi-ye aavaazi-ye Tazieh-ye shahaadat-e hazrat-e Ali Akbar bar asaas-e ejraa-ye goruh-e Tazieh-ye Sarkhong. [An investigation of the vocal music of the mourning play for the martyrdom of Imam Ali Akbar (AS) based on the performance of the Sarkhong mourning group]. Journal of Socio-Cultural Studies of Khorasan, 7(3), 59-86. [In Persian].##Talebian, M.H. & Purali, M. & Hadadi, S. (2021). Miras-e farhangi-e naamalmus-e Iran: miraas-e farhangi-e naamalmus-e sabtshode dar fehrestha-ye melli va Jahaani az ebtedaa ta paaian-e saal-e 1399 [Intangible cultural heritage of Iran: Intangible cultural heritage registered in national and global lists from the beginning until the end of the year 20200]. Tehran: Research Institute of Cultural Heritage, Handicrafts, and Tourism. [In Persian].##Turner, V., & Turner, E. (2021). Communitas and liminality: The forms and characteristics of rites of passage (M. Rasouli, Trans.) [Jama'at-sāra va Āstānagi: Ashkāl va Moshakhasāye Manāsek-e Gozār]. In J. Rahmani & M. Ghorabi (Eds.), A processual approach to culture: The anthropological theory of Victor Turner [Ruykard-e Farayandi be Farhang, Nazariye-ye Ensān-shenākhti-ye Victor Turner]. Tehran: Tisa. [In Persian].##

  • Receive Date 23 July 2024
  • Revise Date 13 August 2024
  • Accept Date 14 August 2024