Journal of Socio-Cultural Studies of Khorasan

Journal of Socio-Cultural Studies of Khorasan

A Phenomenological Study of Lived Experiences of Motherhood in the Folk Music of East Khorasan

Authors
Sahar Tabrizi 1
Golamreza Tabrizikahou 2
1 Master of Art research, Faculty of Art, University of Tarbiat modares, Tehran, Iran.
2 Assistant Professor. Department of Counseling, Faculty of Psychology, University of Attar, Mashhad, Iran.
10.22034/fakh.2025.485432.1694
Abstract
Introduction
The concept of motherhood has undergone significant changes and transformations over time. Archaeological evidence presented by Malinowski highlights that, in early civilizations, motherhood formed the foundation of family structures, with mothers being central to child-rearing and caregiving. In contrast, fathers held marginal and relatively insignificant roles in these early family systems (Mohammadi & Mohammadi, 2021, p. 232). However, contemporary trends have shifted dramatically. Today, women have greater autonomy and the ability to choose whether to embrace motherhood (Omidvar Tehrani et al., 2021, p. 1026).
Modern perspectives regard motherhood as a social category shaped by the cultural and societal positioning of women. According to recent theories, motherhood is influenced by the cultural constructs surrounding women, with art playing a significant role in this dynamic. Art not only reflects a woman's individuality and independence but also shapes and is shaped by her experiences (Amidipour, Rajablo & Bastani, 2024, p. 322). For instance, art can portray the distinctiveness of a mother’s perspective, enhancing her quality of life, while also serving as a medium for artists to embed themes of motherhood in their work. This influence is evident in how the creative output of female artists often transforms before and after they become mothers (Khaleq Panah, Mirzavandian & Rahimi, 2018, p. 73).
In this study, the focus is on music, specifically the folk music of East Khorasan, as a form of art that embodies and expresses these cultural narratives. By employing a phenomenological approach, this research aims to explore and identify the themes emerging from women’s lived experiences of motherhood as reflected in the region’s folk music.
Method
This research employs a phenomenological approach to identify common themes and sub-themes within the intersubjective experiences of individuals who, firstly, have musical expertise and, secondly, are mothers. The primary objective is to describe and analyze the shared experiences of the participants. Phenomenology is particularly well-suited for this purpose, as it facilitates a deeper understanding of people’s lived experiences by exploring their thoughts, emotions, and underlying systems. Additionally, it considers both the visible and hidden aspects of the phenomenon under investigation—in this case, folk music. The study aims to uncover the collective meaning participants assign to their ‘conceptual encounter’ with motherhood. Furthermore, it seeks to represent and analyze their narratives and perceptions of motherhood. To achieve this, the research follows Colaizzi’s seven-step method for phenomenological analysis. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 11 female musicians and music teachers from the city of Mashhad during the winter of 2024. Participants were selected using a stratified sampling method to ensure maximum diversity within the group. The interviews focused on exploring participants’ inner world experiences after engaging with the folk music of East Khorasan. The narratives collected during these interviews were then analyzed using MAXQDA software to extract themes and insights.
 Findings
The findings reveal that the motherhood experiences of female musicians influenced by the folk music of East Khorasan are shaped by various factors, including age, education level, academic field, child’s gender, marital status, and child’s age. The narratives of the participants confirm that these external variables significantly impact their perceptions and experiences of motherhood. A key focus of this research was to analyze and represent the participants’ experiences of motherhood. The women’s perceptions of motherhood were closely tied to their musical experiences. Many participants believed that East Khorasan’s folk music contains themes related to motherhood, which, in turn, influence their personal experiences of being mothers while listening to this music. Through analyzing their narratives, three main themes and ten sub-themes were identified in relation to their motherhood experiences after engaging with folk music.
The participants’ narratives highlighted a sense of motherly hope that emerged while listening to Khorasan’s folk music. This hope was expressed through three core themes:

wish for health for children
hope for independence
wish for a successful marriage for the child

Each theme was explored through detailed participant narratives that illustrated their profound connection to these aspirations. Additionally, the mothers who were also artists described experiencing feelings of anxiety about fulfilling their maternal roles when listening to East Khorasan’s music. This anxiety reflected their concerns and responsibilities as mothers. On the other hand, several participants expressed feelings of happiness and joy after listening to the folk music of East Khorasan, showcasing the multifaceted emotional impact of music on their lived experiences of motherhood.
Discussion and Conclusion
The findings of this research reveal that the music of East Khorasan evokes contradictory experiences of motherhood for many women artists. On one hand, the joy of motherhood enriches their experiences of listening to and engaging with music. On the other hand, anxiety related to fulfilling their maternal roles casts a shadow over these experiences, ultimately contributing to shifts in their identity.
The lived experiences of the artists who are also mothers reflect a structural contradiction in their relationship with the music of East Khorasan and their maternal roles. Two primary themes emerge from their narratives: the joy of embracing motherhood and the concern about performing maternal duties. For some women, engaging with music—whether through listening or active participation—enhances their motivation for motherhood. Conversely, for others, music becomes a space where the demands of their artistic and maternal roles intersect, intensifying feelings of insecurity. This heightened insecurity makes their perception of time more fluid and uncertain. While some participants find harmony between their musical past and their role as mothers, a larger number derive significant satisfaction from their engagement with East Khorasan’s music. However, the ambiguity of time and the conditions it creates disrupt their sense of stability in their maternal roles. Given the increasing number of women active in music, it is essential to establish legal and cultural frameworks to support their dual roles as mothers and artists. These frameworks should aim to alleviate the conflicts they face, ensuring that their musical pursuits do not interfere with their responsibilities as mothers. It is recommended that cultural and artistic authorities acknowledge and adapt to these evolving realities, thereby reducing the intensity of these conflicts. Such measures can help empower women musicians to balance their roles as artists and mothers more effectively.
Acknowledgment
The authors are grateful to the General Directorate of Islamic Guidance of Khorasan Razavi and all the female artists who have given their valuable time to this research.
 
Keywords
Phenomenology
Lived Experience
Khorasan
Motherhood
Folk Music

Subjects

References
Abram, J., & Hinshelwood, R. D. (2021). Paradāym-hā-ye balini-ye Melanie Klein va Donald Winnicott (H. Goudarzi & S. Mohammadian, Trans.) [The clinical paradigms of Melanie Klein and Donald Winnicott]. Tehran: Arjmand. [In Persian]##Amirian, Sh., & Azhand, Y. (2024). Ta’sir-e ravabet-e beynāmati dāstān-e boland-e Mār va Mard dar jalb-e moshārekat-e mokhātab dar jaryān-e khāndane matn (bā dar nazar gereftan-e naghsh-e shakhsiat-e zan dar khānnesh beynāmati-ye asar) [The effect of intertextual relations in the novella Snake and Man on engaging readers: The role of the female character in intertextual reading of the work]. Woman in Culture and Arts, 16(1), 111–132. [In Persian]##De Beauvoir, S. (2023). Jens-e dovom (Q. Sanavi, Trans.) [The second sex]. Tehran: Tous. [In Persian]##Falak-ol-Din, Z., & Hajizadeh Meimandi, M. (2022). Naghshe zanān dar shādkāmi-ye khānavādeh: Motāle’eh-ye keyfi dar shahr-e Yazd [The role of women in family happiness: A qualitative study in Yazd]. Applied Sociology, 33(4), 95–122. [In Persian]##Golabi, F., Alizadeh Aghdam, M. B., & Hosseinzadeh, E. (2023). Sākhtār-e ghodrat-e khānavādeh va rezāyat-e jensi-ye zanān [Family power structure and women’s sexual satisfaction]. Women and Family Studies, 11(4), 20–44. [In Persian]##Hamm, M. (2022). Farhang-e nazariyeh-hā-ye feministi (F. Mohajer, N. Ahmadi Khorasani, & F. Ghareh Daghi, Trans.) [Dictionary of feminist theories]. Tehran: Towse’eh. [In Persian]##Hanna Segal, H. (2007). Yesterday, today and tomorrow. UK. Routledge Prees.##Henriksson, W, H; Williams, A; & Fahlgren, M. (2023). Ambivalent narratives of motherhood and mothering:From normal and natural to not-at-all. Uppsala, Sweden, Macmillan.##Heshemati, A., Amiri, Sh., & Ghanbari, S. (2019). Tadvin-e olgou-ye rābete mādar–koodak bā neshāngānhā-ye ekhtelāl-e delbastegi-ye vākneshi dar koodakān-e 2 tā 5 sāle [Developing a model of mother-child relationship with reactive attachment disorder symptoms in children aged 2 to 5 years]. Family Research, 15(1), 69–88. [In Persian]##Khadem Saba, P., Azkia, M., Safiri, K., & Seifollahi, S. (2022). Tahlil-e paradāymi-ye mafhoum-e zanāneangāri-ye māderi bā ravesh-e nazariye-ye benyādi; mored-e motāle’e: kārmandān-e sherkat-e ābfā-ye manteqe-ye yek-e Tehran [Paradigmatic analysis of the concept of maternal feminization using grounded theory: A case study of employees of Tehran’s Water and Wastewater Company, District 1]. Sociological Studies, 29(2), 305–322. [In Persian]##Khalegh Panah, K., Mirzavandian, F., & Rahimi, M. (2019). Az mādarānegi hamchon ostoureh tā bohran-e mādarānegi: yek khānesh-e neshāneshenākhti bar bāznamāyi-e mādarānegi dar sinemā-ye Iran-e pas az enghelab [From motherhood as a myth to a crisis of motherhood: A semiotic reading of motherhood representation in post-revolution Iranian cinema]. Sociology of Art and Literature, 11(1), 67–88. [In Persian]##Ma, C. (2022). A balancing act: unlearning and embracing Chinese immigrant mothering. Journal of the Motherhood Initiative, 51(2), 341-349.##Mahmoudiyani, S., Ahmadi, A. Y., & Abbasi, K. (2019). Barrasi-ye rabete sākhte ghodrat dar khānavādeh va kanshhā-ye farzandāvari-ye zanān-e shahr-e Lār [An investigation into the relationship between family power structures and women’s fertility behaviors in Lar]. Women’s Strategic Studies, 22(85), 73–98. [In Persian]##Medanlou, M., & Bagherzadeh Ledari, R. (2023). Ezterāb-e salāmat: Moruri-e ravāyati bar modākhelāt-e ravānshenashti [Health anxiety: A narrative review of psychological interventions]. Clinical Excellence, 13(2), 91–100. [In Persian]##Merriam, A. (2022). Ensan-shenāsi-ye mousighi (M. Gharehsou, Trans.) [Anthropology of music]. Tehran: Mahoor. [In Persian]##Mirhosseini, Z., & Kouhpeima Ronizi, Z. (2021). Vākāvi fahm-e edrākshode-ye zanān az āsib-hā-ye houzeh-e khānavādeh (mored-e motāle’eh: zanān-e shahr-e Fasa) [An exploration of women’s perceived understanding of family-related harms: A case study of Women of Fasa]. Strategic Research on Social Issues, 10(1), 71–98. [In Persian]##Mohammad Taghizadeh, M., Karami, M. T., & Saveh, F. (2023). Tajrobe-ye ziste-ye mādarān-e motaleghe az hezānat-e farzandān bā ta’kid bar chalesh-e ezdevāj-e mojaddad [The lived experience of divorced mothers regarding child custody with emphasis on remarriage challenges]. Women’s Strategic Studies, 25(99), 39–62. [In Persian]##Mohammadi, J., & Mohammadi, F. (2021). Tahlil-e goftemān-e barsākhte suje-ye jismmand-e zanāneh dar ertebāt bā soltane mardāneh (zanān-e shahr-e Sanandaj) [Discourse analysis of the constructed embodied female subject in relation to male dominance: A case of women in Sanandaj]. Women’s Research Letter, 12(36), 227–256. [In Persian]##Mousavian, E. (2020). Moruri bar mafhoum-e "oghde-ye mādar-e morde" Andre Green va barrasi-ye tasirat-e ān bar tanzim-e ehssāsāt [A review of André Green’s concept of ‘dead mother complex’ and its effects on emotion regulation]. Psychological Growth, 9(10), 125–134. [In Persian]##Omidipour, Z., Rajablou, A., & Bastani, S. (2024). Suratbandi-ye suje-ye zan-e modern dar goftemānhā-ye dore-ye mashruteh [The formulation of the modern woman subject in the discourses of the Constitutional period]. Women in Development and Politics, 22(2), 319–352. [In Persian]##Omidvar Tehrani, A., Zarani, F., Noheh Sara, S., Panaghi, L., & Malekzadeh Moghani, M. (2021). Edrak az zanānegi dar keshvarhāye mokhtalef: yek farātrakib-e keyfi [Perception of femininity in different countries: A qualitative meta-synthesis]. Psychological Sciences, 20(103), 1015–1038. [In Persian]##Phuong H. T. A, (2017).  Redefining diversity & dynamics of natural resources management in Asia.  Natural Resource Dynamics and Social Ecological Systems in Central Vietnam Prees.##Razaghi, N., Alizadeh, M. A., & Alinejad, K. (2020). Tahlil-e jame’eshenākhti-ye naghsh va jayeghāh-e zanān dar mousighi-ye mardom-pasand: Erā’eh-ye yek nazariye-ye zaminei [Sociological analysis of the role and status of women in popular music: Presenting a grounded theory]. Sociology of Culture and Art, 2(1), 26–47. [In Persian]##Sadeghi Fosaei, S. (2005). Chalesh-e feminizm bā mādarānegi [The feminist challenge with motherhood]. Women’s Strategic Studies, (28), 19–43. [In Persian]##Shabanivarki, B., & Kazemi, S. (2010). Pejoohesh-e keyfi: Ravesh yā bosh? [Qualitative research: Method or approach?]. Cultural Strategy, 19(54), 33–58. [In Persian]##Shiralinia, K., Izadi, M., & Aslani, Kh. (2019). Naghshe vāsetei-ye estres-e farzandparvari, keyfiyat-e rābete mādar-koodak va salāmat-e ravāni-ye mādar dar rabete beyn-e farzandparvari-ye zehndāne va moshkelāt-e raftāri-ye koodakān [The mediating role of parenting stress, mother-child relationship quality, and maternal mental health in the relationship between mindful parenting and children's behavioral problems]. Culture of Counseling and Psychotherapy, 10(38), 135–146. [In Persian]##Tabrizi Kaho, G., Salehi, K., Keshavarz Afshar, H., & Madani, Y. (2023). Paydarshenāsi-ye tajrobe-ye ziste-ye zanān-e sarparast-e khānavār az hemāyat-hā-ye ejtemāi [A phenomenological study of the lived experience of female-headed households with social support]. Applied Sociology, 34(1), 113–138. [In Persian]##Tabrizi, S., Tabrizi Kaho, G., & Boroumand Mahmoudabadi, M. (2024). Barrasi-ye paydārnegāri-ye hemāyat-e ejtemāi dar zanān-e sarparast-e khānavār [A phenomenological investigation of social support in female-headed households]. Women in Development and Politics, 22(2), 487–509. [In Persian]##Yarigarrosh, M. (2022). Tajrobe-ye ziste-ye zanān az zendegi-ye khod va farzandānashān pas az talāgh [The lived experience of women regarding their life and children after divorce]. Culture of Counseling and Psychotherapy, 13(50), 253–274. [In Persian]##Zamanpour, Z., Pakdaman, Sh., Ghanbari, S., & Nejat, P. (2023). Naghshe tadeelgari-ye zarfiat-e tafakkor-e mādar dar rabete beyn-e kholgho khooy-e koodak bā keyfiyat-e rābete mādar–koodak [The moderating role of maternal reflective capacity in the relationship between child temperament and the quality of the mother-child relationship]. Family Research, 19(3), 519–531. [In Persian]##Zargarian, T., Sadeghpour, M. J., & Khazaei, M. (2020). Mokhtasāt-e mafhoumi-ye "tahdid va khatar-e jān-e mādar dar ghavānin-e saght-e darmāni" [Conceptual characteristics of threats and maternal risks in therapeutic abortion laws]. Women and Family Studies, 8(4), 1–20. [In Persian]##

  • Receive Date 25 October 2024
  • Revise Date 18 January 2025
  • Accept Date 21 January 2025